John 21:15-25: “Jesus Restores Peter To Himself And To Ministry

By

Jim Bomkamp

Back          Bible Studies                Home Page

 

1.                  INTRO:

 

1.1.         In our last study we looked at verses 1-14 of chapter 21 of the book of John.

 

1.1.1.  This study concerned Jesus’ appearing to seven of the disciples at the Sea of Tiberias where they had gone fishing and had a rough night of fishing, having caught nothing.  We saw how that these disciples looked back on their previous life before Christ and returned to their previous career as fisherman. 

 

1.1.1.1.We talked about walking in the flesh verses the Spirit for the disciples make this decision to return to fishing on their own, not at the Lord’s leading.

 

1.1.1.2.We looked at how we Christians can become discouraged and how that this can lead to our walking in the flesh.

 

1.1.2.  Jesus appeared to them as a stranger on the shoreline perhaps a hundred yards away and told them to throw their net on the right side of the boat and that they would make a big catch.  For some reason they followed Jesus’ command and threw the net on the right hand side of the boat. 

 

1.1.3.  When the disciples threw the net on the right side of the boat they indeed made a great catch of fish.  Catching these fish at Jesus’ command then caused the disciples to realize that it was in fact Jesus who was the one on the beach. 

 

1.1.4.  Jesus then cooked some fish for them and they ate breakfast.

 

1.2.         In our study today, we are going to look at verses 15-25 of the gospel of John. 

 

1.2.1.  In this study, we will see that Jesus restores Peter to Himself (Peter had denied Jesus three times) and calls Peter to be leader of the entire group of disciples.

 

1.2.2.  Peter had failed and denied the Lord because he didn’t really know himself.  He didn’t realize that there is a sinful nature within each of us and that we cannot trust even our own hearts for the Lord tells us they are “desperately wicked.”  The apostle Paul had come to know himself for he wrote the following in Romans 7:18, “18 For I know that nothing good dwells in me, that is, in my flesh; for the willing is present in me, but the doing of the good is not.”  Paul would later write the following to the Philippians:   Philippians 3:3, “3 for we are the true circumcision, who worship in the Spirit of God and glory in Christ Jesus and put no confidence in the flesh.” The Lord will in this study bring Peter to the point where he no longer will trust in the strength and will power of his own flesh.

 

1.2.3.  Jesus in restoring Peter to Himself removes any trace of self-righteousness within him.  We will see how that the Lord has to reveal to each disciple His sinfulness before he is ready to be effectively used and sent out by Him.

 

1.2.4.  Jesus brings Peter to the end of himself and his own self righteousness as He makes Peter truly come to grips with whether or not and to what extent he really loves Jesus.

 

2.                 VS 21:15-17  - So when they had finished breakfast, Jesus said to Simon Peter, ‘Simon, son of John, do you love Me more than these?’  He said to Him, ‘Yes, Lord;  You know that I love You’.  He said to him, ‘Tend My lambs’.  He said to him again a second time, ‘Simon, son of John, do you love Me?’  He said to Him, Yes, Lord;  You know that I love You’.  He said to him, ‘Shepherd My sheep’.  He said to him the third time, ‘Simon, son of John, do you love Me?’  Peter was grieved because He said to him the third time, ‘Do you love Me?’  And he said to Him, Lord, You know all things;  You know that I love You’.  Jesus said to him, ‘Tend My sheep.’ -  Jesus asks Simon Peter three times if he loves Him, and each time Peter responds that he loves Jesus and then Jesus tells him to feed and tend for His sheep

 

2.1.         In our last study we saw the context of this study.  Jesus had now raised from the dead and even appeared to the disciples corporately on the first evening and then a week later, again on Sunday evening.  Jesus had also appeared to individuals within the disciple ranks.  The disciples had been told to go to Galilee and that the Lord would appear to them.  They had gone to Galilee.  In a snap decision made in the flesh, Peter had decided to go fishing and six of the disciples went with him.  The disciples had gone back to their previous pre-Christian profession of fishing, and done so not at the Lord’s leading.  The disciples had been in their boat fishing all night and were exhausted and frustrated, having caught nothing.  Then, at Jesus’ command (and without their even realizing that it was Him on the shore telling them to do this) they threw their nets on the other side of the boat and their net filled up with fish.  The disciples immediately realized it was Jesus who had done this (he had given them a miraculous catch of fish when they had first been called to follow Him and become fishers of men), and Peter swam to shore while the rest of the disciples came to the shore in the boat with the fish.  When the disciples got to the shore they found Jesus with a charcoal fire and fish already upon the fire. 

 

2.2.         Peter had denied the Lord initially on His last evening when he had followed Jesus to where they had taken Him, and as he was warming himself by the charcoal fire with unbelievers while Jesus was being tried in the next room.  Because Peter had denied Jesus while warming himself at the charcoal fire of the enemy, Jesus decides to restore Peter at this charcoal fire cooking fish for their supper.  These are the only two references to charcoal fires in John’s gospel.

 

2.3.         Peter’s confrontation by Jesus as he was being restored by Jesus was done publicly in front of the other disciples because Peter’s denial was also done publicly.

 

2.4.         As was noted at the beginning of this chapter, Jesus calls Peter by his pre-Christian name of “Simon Peter” all throughout this chapter because it was the pre-Christian self (the old sinful nature) within Peter which caused him to deny Jesus and retreat to living in his former self-life.

 

2.5.         Jesus asks Peter if he loves Him three times because Peter had denied the Lord three times.  However, Jesus was also pressing Peter and trying to impress upon him the importance of his whole-hearted effort in shepherding Christ’s church, to which Jesus was calling him.

 

2.6.         The night before Jesus’ arrest, Peter had boasted of loving Jesus more than all of the rest of the disciples, saying in Matthew 26:33, “Even though all may fall away because of You, I will never fall away.” Now, Jesus asks Peter if after what he had done in denying Jesus three times if he truly believed that he loved Jesus more than the rest of the disciples?  Jesus asks Peter, “’ Simon, son of John, do you love Me more than these?’

 

2.7.         Jesus is getting Peter to the place where he realizes just how inadequate he is in his flesh to resolve to love and serve the Lord.  Peter must come to completely distrust self and the old sinful nature before he will be ready to be able to serve in ministry for the Lord as an apostle.

 

2.8.         Have you ever wondered why Jesus allowed Peter to fall in denying Him those three times?  The Lord could have kept Peter from that temptation, yet He didn’t because He knew that Peter needed to come to the place of brokenness before God before he could ever be effective in ministry.  In Luke 22:32 we see Jesus encouraging Peter telling him that He has prayed for Peter and that after Peter has been restored that he will be usable by God and will then be able to strengthen his brothers, “32 but I have prayed for you, that your faith may not fail; and you, when once you have turned again, strengthen your brothers.””  Peter’s ministry could not have been successful as long as his heart was self-righteous and his trust was in the resolve and will power of his own fleshHH.

 

2.9.         The Greek words that are translated “love” in this section of scripture are very revealing. 

 

2.9.1.  The first two times Jesus asks Peter if he loves Him, Jesus uses the Greek word “agape.” 

 

2.9.1.1.This is the unconditional type of love that defines God’s love and requires commitment and self-abandonment.  It is a love that is unconditional and made as a choice not based upon feelings which can be fickle.  It always seeks the best of the one who is loved.

 

2.9.1.2.Peter replies each time, ‘Yes Lord, You know that I love You.’ 

 

2.9.1.3.Each time Peter seems to correct the Lord, responding that the Lord knows that he loves Him.  However, Peter uses in response the Greek word “phileo,” which is the type of love and affection that is used for where friendship is involved. 

 

2.9.2.  The last time that Jesus asks Peter if he loves Him, He uses the same word for love that Peter had used, “phileo.” 

 

2.9.2.1.Because Jesus uses this same word that Peter had used, which questions Peter’s sincerity, Peter is therefore grieved.  Peter is grieved because the Lord is pressing him to consider the fact that in reality his actions in denying Jesus indicated that Peter didn’t even have the friendship type of love for Jesus.  Peter is grieving then over his own sinfulness and failure.

 

2.9.2.2.Peter doesn’t say, “Yes,” this last time because he is aware of his own inability to love and serve the Lord. 

 

2.9.2.3.Peter responds that Jesus knows all things and that he loves Him, and he uses the Greek word “phileo” for this love.

 

2.9.2.4.Peter’s self-righteousness is now destroyed. 

 

2.10.    Each time that Jesus asks Peter whether he loves Him or not, He then implores him that if it is the case that he loves Jesus, he must show that love by demonstration:  If you love Me then show it by feeding My sheep.”  For us as Christians if our life is not being lived in obedience to Jesus and trying to do those things that He wants us to do in our lives, then how could we say that we truly do love Him?  Jesus once said, “How can you call Me Lord and not do what I say?” 

 

2.11.    In telling Peter to demonstrate his love for Him by feeding and tending His sheep, Jesus is both calling him to ministry and also affirming Peter that he is loved and trusted by Jesus.   

 

2.11.1.The first time, Jesus tells Peter that if he loves Him, he should ‘feed His sheep.’  My translation says that Jesus said ‘tend My Sheep,’ however the word for tend, “bosko” in the Greek, also means to ‘feed,’ and this seems to render the sense of what Jesus is asking. 

 

2.11.2.The second time Jesus tells Peter that if he loves Him, he should show that love by ‘shepherding His sheep,’ however this Greek word translated ‘shepherd’ means “to rule or govern,” and the sense here is that Jesus asks Peter to be a pastor or shepherd ruling over the flock of His disciples which had come together after originally being scattered after His crucifixion. 

 

2.11.3.The third time that Jesus asks Peter if he loves Him, Jesus uses the same word as the first time, “bosko,” however He tells him to show his love by ‘shepherding’ or ‘feeding His little sheep.’ 

 

2.11.3.1.Jesus’ sheep are tender and young, precious in His sight, and Peter must be willing to guard over their souls as a good shepherd guards over the young and tender of his flock.

 

2.12.    The role of a pastor is that of both shepherding as well as feeding.  Just as the 23rd Psalm tells us, the role of the shepherd is to protect from harm, guide, to provide rest, to water, and to feed.   

 

2.13.    Peter has learned finally that Jesus knows everything that is within a man’s heart, and at the same time he knows that he cannot trust himself. 

 

2.14.    However, since Peter denied the Lord and as a result has been severely  humbled, he does not claim anymore to have a superior faith or love than any of the other disciples.  Though Peter is still a bit impetuous, he is now in the place where Jesus can use him, since he no longer has confidence in his flesh, resolve, or wisdom.

 

2.15.    Our motivation for serving Jesus and especially shepherding His sheep must be our deep love for Jesus.  We must do what we do in ministry as unto the Lord, otherwise we shall be only half-hearted in our effort.

 

2.16.    The Lord is asking all Christians whether or not they love Him, and if they love Him, then they must be willing to set aside their own selfish concerns in order to be able to care for His sheep that He places in their lives. 

 

2.16.1.Shall we be the hirelings Jesus taught about in chapter 10 of this gospel, looking out for our own self interests and not truly concerned for the sheep?  Or shall we show our love by imitating the “Good Shepherd” and His care for us?  Shall we flee God’s sheep when we see the wolf coming?  Or, shall we refuse to leave the care of His precious sheep when the wolf comes? 

 

2.16.2.Shall we be concerned for His sheep only when there is something in it for ourselves?  Or, shall we purge any thought from our minds about what we shall receive as a result of our ministering?  God’s sheep are precious in His sight, and He has placed some of them under each of our care.  Our lives should be a reflection of His good care in shepherding us.

 

3.                 VS 21:18  - ‘Truly, truly, I say to you, when you were younger, you used to gird yourself, and walk wherever you wished;  but when you grow old, you will stretch out your hands, and someone else will gird you, and bring you where you do not wish to go’. -  Jesus tells Peter that he must go wherever He leads him

 

3.1.         Some have confused the point that Jesus is making in this verse by saying that Jesus was indicating to Peter that the stretching out of his hands meant the type of death which he was to die, namely crucifixion. 

 

3.2.         Although Jesus is telling Peter that his obedient following of Him would result ultimately in a martyr’s death,  what Jesus was really indicating was that Peter had previous to meeting Jesus done the things he wanted to do and gone where he wanted to go.  However, now Peter was no longer going to do his own will, but God’s will.  This is symbolized in Peter’s girding himself in his previous life, and God girding him when he grew older.  Jesus tells Peter that there will be times when he will have to do things that he would not like to do.

 

3.3.         In John 13:36-38, Peter had told the Lord that he was willing to lay down his life for Jesus, and though Peter had failed the Lord miserably by denying Him, now as Jesus is restoring Peter to Himself and to ministry He tells Peter that he will indeed fulfill that highest honor of laying his life down for Jesus as a Christian martyr, “36 Simon Peter said to Him, “Lord, where are You going?” Jesus answered, “Where I go, you cannot follow Me now; but you will follow later.” 37 Peter said to Him, “Lord, why can I not follow You right now? I will lay down my life for You.” 38 Jesus answered, “Will you lay down your life for Me? Truly, truly, I say to you, a rooster will not crow until you deny Me three times.”

 

3.4.         We Christians must resolve that we have given up our individual rights, and that we have been called not to do our own will, but that His will be done in our life.  We must be willing to be obedient to the Lord, even to the point of death if God calls us to that.

 

4.                 VS 21:19  - Now this He said, signifying by what kind of death he would glorify God.  and when He had spoken this, He said to him, ‘Follow Me!’ -  John tells us that Jesus was telling this to Peter so that Peter would realize that following Jesus would result in martyrdom for him

 

4.1.         In the previous verse, Jesus indicated to Peter that his following of Him would eventually result in a martyr’s death.  Jesus calls Peter once again to follow Him.  Jesus had originally called Peter to follow Him when He began His ministry, and we saw that following Jesus involved following Him in regard to His example in conduct, to be willing to go wherever He wanted him to go, and just to be with Him. 

 

4.2.         Here in this verse, we can hear Jesus saying in this call to ‘follow’ that He wants Peter to continually “abide” in Him as a branch, as Jesus had taught the disciples the day before His crucifixion.

 

4.2.1.  We Christians need to be constantly reminded that we are to be followers of  Jesus, continuously abiding in Him.

 

5.                 VS 21:20-22  - Peter, turning around, saw the disciple whom Jesus loved following them;  the one who also had leaned back on His breast at the supper, and said, ‘Lord, who is the one who betrays You?’  Peter therefore seeing him said to Jesus, ‘Lord, and what about this man?’  Jesus said to him, ‘If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you?  You follow Me!’ -  Peter asks Jesus what will happen to the disciple whom Jesus loved (the apostle John himself), and Jesus replies saying in essence that it is really none of Peter’s business

 

5.1.         Peter saw the apostle John, author of this gospel, following behind them as they were walking.  Over and over again we have seen that John always refers to Himself in this gospel as, ‘the disciple whom Jesus loved.’ 

 

5.2.         Peter wasn’t content to know that he was being called to die a martyr’s death in following Jesus, he wanted to know what would happen to other disciples, and what was the nature of their calling.  Jesus rebuffs Peter for this attitude and tells him in essence that it is none of his business what God is calling other disciples to do or suffer, he must keep his eyes on Jesus and just fulfill his own calling.

 

5.3.         We Christians need to realize that we must not be worried about what other Christians are or aren’t doing in their life.  We need to just keep our eyes on the Lord and not be too worried about what others do. 

 

5.4.         We Christians can become jealous or bitter when we are always keeping our eyes on our brothers and sisters.  We are actually looking back while plowing when we do that, which Jesus said would make us unworthy of His kingdom.  One who is plowing has to keep his eyes straight ahead in order to plow in a straight and consistent manner, and we Christians need to keep our eyes on the Lord and always be sure that we are doing what He wants us to do.

 

5.5.         The Bible Exposition Commentary states the following about taking our eyes off of Jesus and putting them on others:

 

The Lord rebuked Peter and reminded him that his job was to follow, not to meddle into the lives of other believers. Beware when you get your eyes off the Lord and start to look at other Christians! “Looking unto Jesus” should be the aim and practice of every believer (Heb. 12:1–2). To be distracted by ourselves, our circumstances, or by other Christians, is to disobey the Lord and possibly get detoured out of the will of God. Keep your eyes of faith on Him and on Him alone.

This does not mean that we ignore others, because we do have the responsibility of caring for one another (Phil. 2:1–4). Rather, it means that we must not permit our curiosity about others to distract us from following the Lord. God has His plan for us; He also has plans for our Christian friends and associates. How He works in their lives is His business. Our business is to follow Him as He leads us (see Rom. 14:1–13).

I recall a critical time in my own ministry when I was disturbed because other ministers were apparently getting God’s “blessing” in abundance while I seemed to be reaping a meager harvest. I must confess that I envied them and wished that God had given their gifts to me. But the Lord tenderly rebuked me with, “What is that to thee? Follow thou Me.” It was just the message I needed, and I have tried to heed it ever since.

 

6.                 VS 21:23  - This saying therefore went out among the brethren that that disciple would not die;  yet Jesus did not say to him that he would not die, but only, ‘If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you?’ -  John tells us that as a result of this dialog between Peter and Jesus that some who heard this story went around telling others that Peter would never die.

 

6.1.         John includes in this gospel how a false rumor got started as a result of Jesus’ previous teaching.  Some had misunderstood Jesus’ words to Peter concerning John and they thought that Jesus was telling Peter that John would remain alive until Jesus returns for the church.  John corrects that rumor saying that Jesus did not say that John would never die.

 

6.2.         Note here that Jesus tells Peter that He is returning for His church, for He says to Peter, “until I come.”

 

6.3.            Jesus says to Peter, ‘what is that to you.?’ As was mentioned, Jesus already has to give Peter a rebuke here even as He is restoring Peter to Himself, even as Peter has been broken in spirit by the Lord.  Peter’s question has revealed that he has taken his eyes off of Jesus already and begun to look around at others. 

6.4.         There is a motto that makes a lot of sense.  It goes like this, “Look at others, and be distressed. Look at yourself, and be depressed. Look to God, and you’ll be blessed!

 

7.                 VS 21:25  -  “This is the disciple who bears witness of these things, and wrote these things;  and we know that his witness is true.  And there are also many other things which Jesus did, which if they were written in detail, I suppose that even the world itself would not contain the books which were written.”  -  John tells us that if all of the things that Jesus did were written in death that the world itself would fall.

 

7.1.         John reveals that he was the disciple who was following behind Peter and Jesus as they were walking, and thus that he was the one to whom he referred to all throughout his gospel as, “the disciple whom Jesus loved.”

 

7.2.         Using hyperbole, John indicates that Jesus did so many things that His disciples were eye witnesses of, that there would not be room in the world to hold all of the books that could be written of the things that Jesus did.  As John wrote at the end of chapter 20, he only included the stories and teachings of Jesus which he under God’s inspiration deemed necessary so that people might read this book and come to believe in Jesus as their savior and Lord.

 

8.                 The book of John has been a great blessing to us as we have gone verse by verse through it in exactly one year. 

 

9.                 We have seen how that the book was written for the purpose of revealing Jesus as the eternal Son of God incarnate, and thus John picked stories to tell concerning Jesus relative to that theme.  We’ve seen Jesus’ power over all of nature, and we’ve seen His glory in all that He did.  We’ve seen Jesus in control of every situation and incident and that it was only when He willingly laid down His life for mankind that anyone was able to lay a hand on Him.

 

10.            We have seen how that the book was not written so much chronologically but rather based around expounding upon seven signs Jesus performed, 10 discourses He taught, and seven “I am” statements He made:

 

10.1.        The seven signs (attesting miracles) that Jesus performed :

 

10.1.1.Changing water into wine in Cana:  2:1-11.

10.1.2.Healing an official’s son in Capernaum (4: 46-54).

10.1.3.Healing a crippled man at the pool of Bethesda in Jerusalem (5:1-18).

10.1.4.Feeding the 5,000 near the Sea of Galilee (6:5-14).

10.1.5.Walking on the water on the Sea of Galilee (6:16-21).

10.1.6.Healing a blind man in Jerusalem (9:1-7).

10.1.7.  Raising Lazarus from the dead in Bethany (11:1-45).

 

10.2.        The discourses of Jesus found in the gospel of John :

 

10.2.1.On the new birth :  3:1-21.

10.2.2.On the water of life :  4:4-26.

10.2.3.On resurrection and life :  5:19-47.

10.2.4.On the bread of life :  6:26-59.

10.2.5.On the deity of Jesus :  8:12-59.

10.2.6.On the shepherd and flock :  10:1-21.

10.2.7.More on the deity of Jesus :  10:22-38.

10.2.8.On redemption :  12:20-50.

10.2.9.On life while Jesus is gone :  13:31-14:31.

10.2.10.On union with Jesus :  15:1-16:33.

 

10.3.        The seven “I AM” statements of Jesus :

 

10.3.1.I am the Bread of Life :  6:35.

10.3.2.I am the Light of the World :  8:12

10.3.3.I am the Gate for the sheep :  10:7

10.3.4.I am the Good Shepherd :  10:11,14

10.3.5.I am the Resurrection and the Life :  11:25

10.3.6.I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life :  14:6

10.3.7.  I am the True Vine :  15:1.

 

11.            CONCLUSIONS:

 

11.1.    In this epilogue story in the book of John in which Jesus restores Peter to Himself and to ministry, we have learned how we must come to the place in our life where we place no confidence in our own flesh, nor the will power or abilities of the flesh.

 

11.2.    We have also seen how that we need to rid ourselves of self-righteousness and learn to distrust our own hearts and motives.

 

11.3.    We have seen also how that we need to not worry about what brothers and sisters in the Lord are doing or not doing in their life, but concentrate upon our own life and keeping our eyes upon Jesus and doing the things that He has called us to do.

 

11.4.    Jesus asks each of us, “Do you love Me?”  If we do love Him we must demonstrate that love by obeying and following Him, and by shepherding and caring for those whom He puts under our charge.

 

Back          Bible Studies                Home Page